How Dog Training Games Mirror Real Reward Based Training
Every few months a teenager turns up at my puppy class with a parent and announces that they already know how to teach a sit, because they taught one in Nintendogs.

Every few months a teenager turns up at my puppy class with a parent and announces that they already know how to teach a sit, because they taught one in Nintendogs. Then they hold the treat a foot above the puppy's head, say "sit" six times, and wonder why the puppy jumps at their hand. I am never annoyed by it. The game taught them something real, and the part it got wrong is easy to fix in about ten minutes.
Dog training games borrow more from reward based training than most people notice. They also simplify it in ways that cause predictable mistakes the first time the player meets a real dog. Here is where the overlap sits and where it breaks, from someone who has taught group classes for more than ten years.
How the games teach a trick
Nintendogs, on the DS and later the 3DS, has the cleanest model. You get the dog into a position, say a sit, by stroking its back with the stylus. A small light bulb icon appears above the dog's head. You tap it and say the cue word into the microphone. Repeat that over several sessions and the dog starts responding to your voice alone. Skip practice for a while and it gets sloppier.
The Sims 4 Cats and Dogs, from 2017, takes a different approach. You cannot teach a sit, but you can shape behaviors. When a dog begs at the table, jumps on furniture or chews something, your Sim can praise or scold it, and a hidden meter moves the dog toward or away from that habit. Enough consistency and the behavior sticks.
Both games are built on the same idea that real trainers rely on: behavior that pays off gets repeated, and repetition across days matters more than one long session.
What the games get right about reward based training
The light bulb in Nintendogs is the closest thing in gaming to a clicker. In real training a marker, either a clicker or a short word like "yes", tells the dog the exact moment it did the right thing. Then the treat follows. The game makes you mark the moment the dog is already in position, not before and not after, and that is the single most important skill in my classes.
The games also get the session length right by accident. A Nintendogs training round is short, a minute or two. Real puppies learn best in sessions of three to five minutes, two or three times a day. Most new owners try for twenty minutes on a Saturday and end up with a bored, nippy puppy and a frustrated human.
The third match is fading. In Nintendogs you stop needing the stylus once the dog knows the word. In real life you move from luring with a treat in your hand, to a hand signal with no treat visible, to a word alone, with the reward arriving after the behavior instead of leading it. Players who have watched the game do that tend to understand the idea quickly.
Where they mislead you
Timing is the big one. The game freezes the dog in place while you tap and talk. A real puppy holds a sit for perhaps a second and a half before it pops up to investigate your shoelaces. If your "yes" comes after the bottom leaves the floor, you have marked the stand. I ask new owners to say "yes" the instant the bottom touches, and the treat can follow within three seconds.
The voice is the second one. Nintendogs needs you to say the word, so players get into the habit of repeating it until the dog does it. Real dogs learn that "sit sit sit SIT" is the cue, which is why the teenager's puppy ignored the first five. Say it once. If nothing happens, help with a lure and try again later.
The Sims gets one thing wrong that matters a lot. Scolding works in the game as well as praise does. In real dogs, scolding mostly teaches the dog to do the thing when you are not looking, and it can make a nervous dog worse. Interrupt, redirect, and reward the alternative.
"Wean them off treats as soon as possible" is overrated
The most common advice I hear from relatives, neighbors and the occasional forum is that treats are bribery and the goal is a dog that works for praise alone. The sooner you stop the food, the better trained the dog.
I disagree, and so do most trainers I have worked alongside. Praise is a reward for some dogs, mostly ones who already have a strong bond with the person, but for a ten week puppy a pat on the head is close to meaningless compared with a piece of chicken. Pulling the food early is how a reliable sit in the kitchen turns into no sit at all at the park.
What you actually do is move from rewarding every sit to rewarding most of them, then some of them, with the best rewards saved for hard situations. The food never fully disappears for difficult skills like a recall or settling when the doorbell rings. That is not bribery. A bribe is shown before the behavior. A reward comes after it. The games handle that difference better than the advice does, since the dog in Nintendogs never sees the treat first.
A five minute session built from the game loop
This is how I teach a sit to complete beginners who learned on a console. It follows the game's loop on purpose, because they already understand it.
- Have ten pea sized treats ready in a pouch, not in your hand.
- Lure: hold one treat at the puppy's nose and lift it slowly back over the head, about two inches up. The bottom drops.
- Mark: say "yes" the moment the bottom touches. This is your light bulb.
- Reward: give the treat within three seconds, at the puppy's mouth level so it stays sitting.
- Repeat five times, then do five with an empty hand making the same motion, rewarding from the pouch.
- Add the word "sit" only once the puppy is dropping its bottom as your hand moves, usually by the second or third session.
- Stop while it is still going well, before the ten treats run out.
Run that twice a day for four days and most puppies in my class have a sit that works in the kitchen. Taking it to new places is its own project. Settling on a mat is the next skill I teach, and the steps are in teaching a dog to settle down when guests arrive. Everything else lives in the training and behavior section.
FAQ
Can Nintendogs teach you how to train a real dog?
It teaches the idea of marking the right moment and keeping sessions short. It does not teach the speed a real dog moves at, so practice your timing without the dog first.
Is a clicker better than saying yes?
A clicker is slightly more precise, but a short word works well and is always with you. Pick one and keep it consistent.
How many treats is too many in a training session?
Use tiny pieces and count them toward the daily food amount. Ten to fifteen pea sized treats per session is normal for a puppy.
Does scolding a dog work like it does in The Sims?
Not well. It tends to teach a dog to hide the behavior rather than stop it. Redirecting and rewarding a better choice works faster.
More in Games
Games
Explore Game Sessions That Fit Around a Dog Walking Routine
My Border Collie cross, Juniper, has a very specific stare she gives me at about 5:40 in the evening.
Games
How Virtual Vet Games Help Players Spot Signs of a Sick Pet
The most useful thing an owner can bring to the clinic is not a theory about what is wrong. It is an observation.
Games
Why Online Gaming Pets Need Feeding Schedules Like Real Ones
A woman at the clinic desk once showed me her phone while she waited for her cat's weigh-in.